Marathon’s Oldest Operating Restaurant!

Servin’ Fresh Local Seafood, The Best Craft Beer Selection in the Florida Keys and Awesome Key Lime Pie!

Thank you for visiting Herbie’s! We capture the essences of “The Keys” flavors with innovative recipes… some from the “old days” and others created right here. We’ve taken the best of traditional Keys cuisine and put our own unique twist on them — recipes you are certain to love! Our kitchen prepares every dish from “scratch” meaning it’s fresh and as local and in season as possible. Herbie’s has been serving locals and tourists alike for 50 years. But, under it’s former ownership(s), this little Florida Keys shack has been operating since the 1940’s!

Don’t let the outside fool you… This is the biggest little restaurant you will ever walk in to!  Whether you take door number 1 – the main room, door number 2 – the front room, or door number 3 – the screened in porch, it’s all the same great food, great beer and great service!




We have a great selection of popular seafood and a unique array of craft beer on tap.


24 fresh craft beers on tap, every day!












We call it, “The Bananas.”

 Most menu items are available for take out too!

And, don’t forget one of our amazing desserts!









Open: Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday 

 12:00pm ~ 9:00pm

Address: 6350 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 33050-2729

Phone Number: 305-743-6373